Commission caps directly hurt AE hiring and retention. When top-performing Account Executives see their earning potential artificially limited, they leave for competitors who offer uncapped OTE structures. This is not a minor inconvenience for your business; it is a structural problem that shapes who applies, who stays, and who consistently hits quota.
The relationship between base salary vs. OTE is one of the most scrutinized factors in any AE hiring conversation. And in European B2B SaaS markets, where competition for commercial talent is intensifying, getting this wrong is increasingly expensive. Below, we break down every angle of this question.
Why do commission caps cause top AEs to leave?
Top AEs leave because commission caps remove the primary financial incentive that drives high performance. When an Account Executive consistently closes above quota, a cap signals that their extra effort earns them nothing. High performers are disproportionately motivated by upside potential, and a cap effectively penalizes success. The best talent will always find a role where overperformance is rewarded.
This is not speculation. When we speak to senior AEs who are open to new opportunities, one of the first questions they ask is whether the plan is capped. Those who have hit a cap before describe it as demoralizing. They closed the deal, they delivered the revenue, and then the company kept the difference.
The retention risk is compounded by the fact that it is almost always the strongest performers who leave first. Average performers may stay because they rarely hit the cap anyway. What you are left with is a team weighted toward the middle, and the game-changing talent you hired is now closing deals for a competitor.
What’s the difference between capped and uncapped commission structures?
A capped commission structure sets a maximum payout regardless of how much an AE closes. An uncapped structure pays out proportionally no matter how far above quota an AE performs. The difference is not just financial; it signals how a company views its salespeople and whether it trusts them to drive revenue beyond a fixed ceiling.
In practice, capped plans often include a hard stop at a percentage of OTE, for example 150% or 200% of target. Once an AE reaches that threshold, additional deals generate no personal income. Uncapped plans continue to pay out, sometimes with accelerators that increase the commission rate above quota, rewarding overperformance at a higher multiple.
The base salary vs. OTE ratio matters here too. A high base with a capped commission can work for AEs who value stability, particularly in enterprise sales cycles where deals close slowly. But for mid-market AEs who close frequently and have real control over volume, an uncapped plan with a competitive base is almost always more attractive.
How do commission caps affect the quality of AE candidates you attract?
Commission caps filter out the candidates who are most confident in their own ability to perform. When a strong AE evaluates your role, they are assessing whether they can make more money with you than elsewhere. A cap tells them the answer is no, above a certain point. The candidates who remain unbothered by a cap tend to be those who do not expect to exceed it.
This creates a self-selection problem. Your job posting, your interviews, and your offer process may all look strong. But the structural signal sent by a capped OTE Account Executive plan quietly filters your pipeline. You end up interviewing candidates who are comfortable with average outcomes rather than those who are betting on themselves.
In a market where specialized B2B SaaS talent is genuinely scarce, this matters more than most hiring managers realize. The pool of AEs with a track record in enterprise or mid-market SaaS sales, with relevant vertical experience, and who are actively looking is already small. Capping their upside shrinks that pool further.
Should you remove commission caps to improve retention?
Removing commission caps improves retention of high performers, but it needs to be paired with a well-designed plan to avoid unintended costs. Simply uncapping a broken commission structure can create financial exposure without solving the underlying performance problem. The decision to remove caps should be part of a broader review of how your OTE Account Executive structure is built.
Before removing caps, consider whether your quota-setting is accurate and fair. An uncapped plan only works if quotas are challenging but realistic. If quotas are set too low, uncapping can create outsized payouts that feel disconnected from business value. If quotas are too high, removing the cap is irrelevant because AEs never get close to it anyway.
The companies that retain the best commercial talent tend to combine a competitive base salary, an uncapped commission structure, and accelerators above 100% of quota. This design communicates trust, rewards excellence, and keeps your strongest AEs motivated to keep selling well into the back half of the year rather than coasting once they have hit their number.
What compensation structures do top-performing AEs actually look for?
Top-performing AEs look for a competitive base salary, an uncapped commission plan, and accelerators that reward overperformance. The exact base salary vs. OTE split they prefer varies by seniority and sales cycle length, but the consistent requirement is that the plan should not punish them for closing more than expected. Transparency and simplicity in how commission is calculated also rank highly.
In conversations with senior AEs across Benelux and DACH, a few patterns come up consistently. First, they want to understand the plan before the offer stage. Vague answers about commission structure during the hiring process are a red flag for experienced candidates. Second, they want to know the average and top-end earnings of peers in similar roles. This tells them whether the OTE is theoretical or genuinely achievable.
Third, and often underestimated, they want to know how commission is paid when deals involve renewals, expansions, or multi-year contracts. The mechanics of the plan matter as much as the headline number. A strong OTE Account Executive package that falls apart on deal structure details will lose you candidates at the finish line.
How do commission caps compare across European SaaS markets?
Commission caps are less common in the Nordics and DACH markets than in some other regions, partly because the talent pool in those markets is smaller and candidates have more negotiating leverage. In Benelux, capped plans exist but are increasingly scrutinized by experienced AEs who have worked at US-headquartered SaaS companies and are familiar with more competitive structures.
Market norms vary, but the direction of travel across European SaaS markets is toward uncapped plans, particularly for mid-market and enterprise AEs. Companies expanding into new European markets often discover that local candidates benchmark compensation against the most competitive employers in their region. Arriving with a capped plan while competing for talent against well-funded scale-ups is a structural disadvantage.
In DACH specifically, where the SaaS talent market has matured significantly in recent years, senior AEs are increasingly sophisticated about compensation benchmarking. The same is true in the Nordics, where a smaller talent pool means top performers have more options and less reason to accept a cap. Understanding these regional dynamics is essential before setting your compensation structure for a new-market hire.
What are the hidden costs of losing an AE to a competitor with no cap?
The hidden costs of losing an AE to a competitor with an uncapped plan extend well beyond the immediate vacancy. You lose the revenue that AE would have generated, the institutional knowledge they carry, the relationships they hold with prospects in your pipeline, and the time and cost required to find, hire, and ramp a replacement. When you add these together, the cost of a single AE departure is substantial.
Ramp time is one of the most overlooked factors. A new AE typically takes several months before they are consistently closing deals at full capacity. During that period, your pipeline stalls, your team absorbs additional pressure, and your revenue targets slip. If the departing AE was a strong performer, the gap is even more visible.
There is also a competitive intelligence risk. An AE who joins a direct competitor brings knowledge of your pricing, your sales methodology, your key accounts, and the objections your product faces in the market. This is not a reason to avoid hiring great people, but it is a reason to take retention seriously before a cap becomes the reason they leave.
The mis-hire and the avoidable departure are two of the most expensive events in any commercial team’s lifecycle. Both are preventable with the right structure in place from the start.
At Nobel Recruitment, we speak to hundreds of GTM candidates and hiring managers every week. Curious what we’re seeing in the market right now? Reach out, we’re happy to share, or take a look at how we approach GTM executive search.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if our current commission structure is causing us to lose top AE candidates before they even apply?
The clearest signal is a drop-off in applications from senior AEs with strong track records, or candidates going quiet after an initial conversation about compensation. If your recruiter or hiring manager is hearing objections around earning potential early in the process, the structure is likely filtering out high performers before they reach the interview stage. Benchmarking your OTE and cap thresholds against what well-funded competitors in your region are offering is the fastest way to identify whether you have a structural problem.
What's a realistic accelerator structure to pair with an uncapped commission plan?
A common and effective approach is to pay the standard commission rate up to 100% of quota, then increase the rate to 1.25x or 1.5x for every deal closed above that threshold. Some companies add a second accelerator tier at 150% of quota, pushing the multiplier higher to reward exceptional overperformance. The key is to make the accelerator meaningful enough that an AE closing at 130% of quota feels a tangible financial difference compared to closing at 100%, which is what keeps top performers selling hard in Q4 rather than coasting.
Can a high base salary compensate for a capped commission structure when hiring senior AEs?
For some AE profiles, particularly those in long-cycle enterprise sales where deal volume is low and income predictability matters, a higher base can partially offset the appeal of an uncapped plan. However, for mid-market AEs who close frequently and have real control over their output, a higher base rarely compensates for a cap because the upside potential is what drives their motivation and their choice of employer. The risk is that a high base with a cap attracts candidates who prioritise stability over performance, which may not align with the commercial profile you actually need.
How should we handle commission on renewals and expansions when designing an uncapped plan?
This is one of the most common points of failure in otherwise well-designed compensation plans. At minimum, AEs should receive a clearly defined commission rate on expansions they actively drive, even if renewals are managed by a separate Customer Success function. If your AEs are involved in multi-year contract negotiations or upsell motions, those mechanics need to be spelled out before the offer is signed, not discovered after the first renewal cycle. Ambiguity here is a genuine reason experienced candidates decline offers or leave once they realise the headline OTE does not reflect how deals actually pay out.
What's the biggest mistake companies make when removing commission caps for the first time?
The most common mistake is uncapping the plan without revisiting quota accuracy at the same time. If quotas are set too low, removing the cap can result in payouts that feel disconnected from business value and create internal tension around compensation fairness. Before removing caps, audit whether your quotas are genuinely challenging for a strong performer, and model out what your commission liability looks like if your top two or three AEs close at 150% of quota. The goal is a plan where overperformance is rewarded generously but quotas are set at a level that makes those payouts feel earned on both sides.
How do we communicate a new uncapped commission structure to existing AEs without creating scepticism?
Transparency is the most important factor. Present the new plan with worked examples showing exactly what an AE earns at 80%, 100%, 120%, and 150% of quota, so the numbers are concrete rather than theoretical. If you are also adjusting base salaries or quota levels at the same time, explain the reasoning clearly and give AEs time to ask questions before the plan goes live. Scepticism usually comes from past experience of plans that looked good on paper but paid out differently in practice, so showing your working and being specific about edge cases goes a long way toward building trust in the new structure.
At what company stage does it make the most sense to move from a capped to an uncapped commission model?
The right moment is typically when you are scaling your commercial team beyond the first few AEs and actively competing for experienced mid-market or enterprise talent in the open market. Early-stage companies sometimes use caps as a financial safety net when revenue is unpredictable, which is understandable, but this approach becomes a hiring liability once you are operating in a competitive talent market. If you are expanding into a new European region and hiring your first local AEs, arriving with an uncapped structure from day one signals maturity and competitiveness, which matters significantly when candidates are weighing you against established players.
Related Articles